On this page
An interview scorecard is a one-page form that lists the four to six things the job really needs and gives each a 1 to 5 rating, so every interviewer scores every candidate on the same things, straight after the interview. It turns "I liked them" into comparable numbers backed by written evidence. Below is a free template you can copy into Word, Google Docs or Excel, a worked example with the maths, and the rules that make scorecards work.
Why use an interview scorecard
Without a scorecard, interviews drift. Each interviewer remembers different things, the most confident candidate gets the benefit of the doubt, and the panel debate turns into a contest of impressions. A scorecard fixes that in four ways:
- Everyone is compared on the same criteria. You stop comparing a candidate's best answer with another's weakest.
- Decisions rest on evidence. Each score has a note: what the candidate actually said or did.
- The panel can agree faster. Disagreements become specific ("you gave problem solving a 2, what did you hear?") instead of general.
- You have a record. If a candidate asks why they were not successful, or a manager asks why you chose someone, you have more than a feeling to point to.
It also pairs naturally with an earlier step. Before interviews, a person specification or a ranked shortlist tells you which criteria matter; the scorecard is how you test them face to face.
Interview scorecard template (copy and edit)
Header: Candidate name · Role · Interviewer · Date · Interview stage
| # | Criterion | Weight | What a 4 or 5 looks like | Score (1 to 5) | Evidence: what they said or did |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Core skills for the role | 30% | Describes doing the main tasks well, with specific examples | ||
| 2 | Relevant experience | 25% | Has done similar work at similar scale or complexity | ||
| 3 | Communication | 15% | Clear, structured, listens and answers the question asked | ||
| 4 | Problem solving | 15% | Works through a problem step by step and explains why | ||
| 5 | Motivation and working style | 15% | Knows why this role, and how they work best | ||
| Weighted total | 100% |
Footer: Overall recommendation (Hire / Maybe / Do not hire) · Concerns or follow-ups · Interviewer signature
The rating scale
Print this on the form so every interviewer uses the same meaning for each number.
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 1 | No evidence, or evidence of a clear problem |
| 2 | Some evidence, but below what the role needs |
| 3 | Meets the requirement, with an adequate example |
| 4 | Strong: a clear, relevant example with a good result |
| 5 | Outstanding: several strong examples, clearly beyond the requirement |
How to calculate the weighted total
Multiply each score by its weight and add them up:
Weighted total = (score 1 × weight 1) + (score 2 × weight 2) + … for every criterion
Weights are written as decimals in the maths: 30% is 0.30. They must add up to 100%.
Worked example: customer service advisor
Say you are hiring a customer service advisor and your criteria and weights are: communication 30%, problem solving 25%, customer focus 25%, reliability 10% and role knowledge 10%. Three candidates, scored 1 to 5:
| Criterion (weight) | Candidate A | Candidate B | Candidate C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Communication (30%) | 4 | 4 | 5 |
| Problem solving (25%) | 3 | 4 | 3 |
| Customer focus (25%) | 5 | 3 | 2 |
| Reliability (10%) | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| Role knowledge (10%) | 3 | 2 | 4 |
| Weighted total | 3.90 | 3.65 | 3.45 |
How candidate A's total is worked out: (4 × 0.30) + (3 × 0.25) + (5 × 0.25) + (4 × 0.10) + (3 × 0.10) = 1.20 + 0.75 + 1.25 + 0.40 + 0.30 = 3.90.
Candidate A leads, but look at how the others got there. B is strong on problem solving and reliability but weaker on customer focus, the criterion you weighted heavily. C is the most articulate but struggled to show customer focus. A close result like this should start a conversation about the evidence, not end it.
How to build your own scorecard in five steps
- Start from the job. Take the essential criteria from your job description or person specification. If you are starting from scratch, our job description templates help.
- Pick four to six criteria. More than six and interviewers cannot hold them in their head, and scores become noise.
- Weight them to 100%. Give the criteria that decide success in the role the biggest share.
- Write one or two questions per criterion. Behavioural questions work well: "Tell me about a time when…". Our guide to competency-based interview questions has examples for common competencies.
- Define a 1, 3 and 5 before the first interview. Agree what each looks like for each criterion. This is the step most teams skip, and the one that makes scores comparable.
Rules for using a scorecard well
- Score straight after the interview, before discussing. If interviewers compare notes first, the loudest voice sets everyone's scores.
- Write evidence, not adjectives. "Gave an example of calming an angry customer by offering a callback within the hour" beats "good communicator".
- Ask every candidate the same core questions in the same order. Follow-ups can vary; the main questions should not.
- Score only what is on the form. Do not let things unrelated to the job influence scores. In the UK, the Equality Act 2010 protects against discrimination based on age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation.
- Write notes you would be comfortable with the candidate reading. Under UK GDPR, people can ask for the personal data an employer holds about them, and interview notes can fall within that. Decide how long you will keep scorecards for unsuccessful candidates and say so in your privacy notice.
- Treat the total as input, not the verdict. A person still makes the hiring decision, using the scores, the evidence and any concerns.
Common mistakes
- Too many criteria. Eight or ten criteria spread attention thin and make every score less reliable.
- No weights. If everything counts equally, a nice-to-have can outweigh a must-have.
- A vague scale. If "3" means different things to different interviewers, the totals are not comparable.
- Scoring from memory days later. Details fade quickly; score within the hour.
- Changing the criteria mid-process. If you realise a criterion is wrong, fix it for everyone and rescore, rather than quietly applying new standards to later candidates.
Where a scorecard fits with AI CV screening
Scorecards work at the interview stage. Before that, the problem is usually volume: more CVs than anyone can read properly. AI candidate ranking reads every CV against your job description and gives each candidate a score with written reasons, so you interview the strongest people. Using the same must-haves in both places keeps the process consistent: the criteria that put someone on your shortlist are the criteria you test in the room. A person makes the shortlisting decision and the hiring decision in both cases. You can try SwiftShortlist free on one role, or see how it works on a real job.
Frequently asked questions
How many criteria should an interview scorecard have? Four to six. Fewer than four rarely captures the job; more than six makes it hard to score reliably.
Should I use a 1 to 5 or a 1 to 4 scale? Both work. A 1 to 5 scale is the most common and has a clear middle. A 1 to 4 scale has no middle, which pushes interviewers to commit to "slightly above" or "slightly below" the requirement.
Should interviewers see each other's scores? Only after each person has submitted their own. Then compare, and ask each interviewer to explain their evidence for any criterion where scores differ by two or more points.
Is an interview scorecard legally required in the UK? No. There is no legal requirement to use one. It is good practice because it supports fair, consistent decisions and gives you a record of why you chose someone.
Can I use a scorecard for phone screens? Yes. Use a shorter version with two or three criteria, such as availability, core skills and motivation, and keep the full scorecard for later interview stages.
What should I do if two candidates score almost the same? Look at the evidence behind the criteria that matter most for the role, check for concerns, and consider a short follow-up task or conversation. A gap of a few tenths of a point is not a strong signal on its own.
Try SwiftShortlist free
Upload CVs and get an AI-ranked shortlist in minutes. No sign-up for your first 2 CVs.