Reference Check Questions: 25 Questions to Ask, with a Free Template (UK)

25 reference check questions to ask a candidate's previous employer, a copy-and-paste template, UK rules on consent and health questions, and how to read a weak reference.

SwiftShortlistPublished 8 min read
On this page
  1. What a reference check is for
  2. When to do reference checks
  3. Before you call: a short checklist
  4. 25 reference check questions
  5. Reference check template (copy and edit)
  6. How to run the call
  7. What the UK rules say
  8. How to read a reference
  9. What to do if references are weak or hard to get
  10. References and AI CV screening
  11. Frequently asked questions

Reference check questions are the structured questions you ask a candidate's previous employer or manager to confirm what they told you at interview and to learn how they work. A good reference check takes 10 to 15 minutes, uses the same core questions for every finalist, and focuses on evidence: what the person did, how well, and in what circumstances. Below are 25 reference check questions grouped by purpose, a template you can copy, the UK rules to know, and how to spot a weak or evasive reference.

What a reference check is for

A reference check does three jobs:

  • Confirms the facts. Job title, dates of employment and main responsibilities match what the candidate said.
  • Tests your impressions. You heard strong answers at interview. A referee can tell you whether the day-to-day reality matches.
  • Helps you manage the person. What they need to do their best work, and what to watch for, is useful before the first week.

It is not a way to look for reasons to reject someone you already want to hire, and it is not a replacement for a structured interview. Use it at the end of the process, once you have a clear preferred candidate, as one more piece of evidence.

When to do reference checks

Most employers check references after a conditional offer, or just before one, and for finalists only. That is usually the best timing because:

  • You avoid contacting a current employer before the candidate has agreed to it.
  • Referees' time is not wasted on people who will not be hired.
  • The offer can be made conditional on satisfactory references, so you have a clear route if something serious comes up.

Tell the candidate you plan to take references and ask who they would like you to contact. Get their agreement before you approach a current employer.

Before you call: a short checklist

  1. Get written consent from the candidate, and the referee's name, role and contact details.
  2. Ask for the right kind of referee. A line manager from the most recent relevant job is ideal. A colleague or a friend is not a substitute.
  3. Decide your questions beforehand, based on the main requirements in your person specification or interview scorecard.
  4. Choose phone or written. A phone call gets more candid answers. A written form creates a record and suits referees who cannot talk.
  5. Block 15 minutes and take notes as you go.

25 reference check questions

Opening and verification

  1. How do you know the candidate, and for how long did you work together?
  2. What was their job title, and what were their dates of employment?
  3. What were their main responsibilities?
  4. Who did they report to, and were they managing anyone?

Performance and results

  1. How would you describe their overall performance in the role?
  2. What were their biggest achievements while working with you?
  3. How did they handle their workload and deadlines?
  4. How did they respond when something went wrong or priorities changed?
  5. Can you give me an example of work you were particularly pleased with?

Skills and working style

  1. What are their strongest skills?
  2. How would you describe how they work with colleagues and other teams?
  3. How did they take feedback or coaching?
  4. How did they communicate, in writing and in person?
  5. How much supervision did they need?

Development and fit for the role

  1. What would you say are the areas where they could develop further?
  2. What kind of manager or environment gets the best out of them?
  3. I am hiring for [role], which involves [two or three key tasks]. How do you think they would do?
  4. Is there anything that would help us manage and support them well?

Reliability and conduct

  1. How was their attendance and timekeeping? (Ask about reliability generally, not about health or sickness. See the UK rules below.)
  2. Were there any conduct or performance concerns that you are able to share?
  3. Why did they leave, or why are they leaving?

Closing questions

  1. Would you work with them again?
  2. Would you re-hire them, if the opportunity arose?
  3. Is there anything else I should know that would help me make a good decision?
  4. Is there anyone else who worked closely with them whom I could speak to?

Questions 22 and 23 are often the most revealing. A pause, a hedge or a very careful answer is a signal worth following up.

Reference check template (copy and edit)

Header: Candidate name · Role applied for · Referee name and job title · Company · Date · Method (phone or email) · Consent confirmed (yes/no)

Area Question Referee's answer (notes) Matches interview?
Verification Dates, job title, responsibilities
Performance Overall performance and achievements
Skills Strongest skills, relevant to [role]
Working style Teamwork, communication, feedback
Development Areas to develop
Reliability Reliability and conduct
Re-hire Would you work with or re-hire them?

Summary: Satisfactory / Satisfactory with notes / Not satisfactory · Checked by · Date

How to run the call

  • Introduce yourself and the purpose. "Hello, I am [name] from [company]. [Candidate] has given your name as a referee for a [role] position. Do you have 10 minutes to talk?"
  • Confirm they are happy to give the reference, and say the candidate has agreed to the contact.
  • Start with open questions and let them talk. Use follow-ups such as "Can you give me an example?"
  • Use the same core questions for every finalist. That keeps the check fair and comparable.
  • Take notes of what was said, not your interpretation of it.
  • Thank them. Referees are doing you a favour.

What the UK rules say

  • Employers are not generally required to give a reference. Many only confirm dates and job title as a matter of policy. Some regulated sectors, such as financial services, have specific requirements.
  • If a reference is given, it must be accurate and fair. An employer owes a duty of care to both the person who is the subject of the reference and the one who receives it, and it must not be misleading.
  • Do not ask about health or sickness before making an offer. Under the Equality Act 2010, an employer generally may not ask about a candidate's health or disability before offering the job, except in narrow circumstances. Questions about sickness absence in a reference are therefore risky. Ask about reliability and attendance in general terms.
  • Treat candidates equally. Do not ask questions linked to age, sex, race, religion, pregnancy or any other protected characteristic. Using the same questions for each finalist helps.
  • Handle the notes carefully. References contain personal data. Keep them securely, share them only with the people who need them, and follow your retention policy. A candidate can ask what personal data you hold about them.

For definitive guidance, see GOV.UK, Acas and the ICO. This is general information, not legal advice.

How to read a reference

What you hear What it may mean What to do
Specific examples and numbers Strong, genuine reference Note the evidence
Warm but vague ("great person") May be hiding something, or may just be busy Ask for an example
Dates or title do not match Possible error or exaggeration Ask the candidate to explain, calmly
Long pause on "would you re-hire?" A reservation Ask what would make them hesitate
Only confirms title and dates Company policy, not a bad sign Ask for a second referee
Contradicts what was said at interview A serious issue Give the candidate a chance to respond before you decide

One negative comment should not decide it on its own. Look for patterns, check the context, and give the candidate a chance to respond to anything serious.

What to do if references are weak or hard to get

  • Ask for more referees. People change jobs, and some employers refuse.
  • Accept a character or colleague referee if there is no manager, but weigh it accordingly.
  • Use a work trial or short task if the role allows it.
  • Rely on your structured interview evidence. A reference is one input, not the verdict.
  • Make any offer conditional, so you can withdraw it fairly if something serious comes up.

References and AI CV screening

Reference checks come at the end of the process. Earlier steps decide who gets there. AI candidate ranking reads every CV against your job description and gives each candidate a score with written reasons, so you spend your interview and reference time on the strongest people. A person makes every hiring decision. You can try SwiftShortlist free on one role.

Frequently asked questions

How many references should I get? Two is common: ideally the most recent line manager and one other. For senior roles, three.

Should I contact the current employer? Only with the candidate's permission, and usually after a conditional offer. Contacting a current employer without agreement can put the candidate's job at risk.

Can an employer refuse to give a reference in the UK? Generally yes. Many give only a factual reference. Some regulated sectors require more.

What if the reference is negative? Check the context, look for patterns, and let the candidate respond to anything serious. Do not decide on one comment.

Can I ask a referee about sickness absence? It is risky. Under the Equality Act 2010, employers generally should not ask about health or disability before making an offer. Ask about reliability and attendance in general terms.

How long should a reference check take? A phone call of 10 to 15 minutes. A written form takes the referee about the same, and often longer to come back.

Can I do a reference check by email? Yes. A form with the same questions works, and leaves a record. A phone call usually gets more honest detail.

Try SwiftShortlist free

Upload CVs and get an AI-ranked shortlist in minutes. No sign-up for your first 2 CVs.

Try it free